Oh, The Humanity!
"You're no special agent; you're just some jerk who hates my mustache!" -The Tick
Hooray! I have sucessfully made two test cookies that didn't crumble and fall off the sticks. The dough that was mostly eggs and flour ended up holding together really well after it was chilled. I could almost pick up the raw cookie without a spatula. And it was firm enough to actually insert the stick in it, instead of have to smoosh it into one side of the cookie (which automatically gives the cookie a "bad side"). But I purchased my secret weapon today at Lowes. One 1/4 inch dowel, split in half and taped down to the table makes and EXCELLENT guide for your rolling pin. My dough was the perfect thickness all the way around, which vastly improved cooking time.
So, does everyone know how hard it is to make cut-out cookies? It's hard. It gives me a whole new level of respect for moms in general. It is messy, messy, complicated work. And my current sugar cookie experiments have been complicated by a few additional things. 1) My kitchen is small. No counter space means I am rolling cookies out on the sheets. 2) Eric keeps eating the dough 3) I have to have about...oh...6 dozen wedding-themed sugar cut-out cookies on sticks in 6 days to make into centerpieces for my sister's shower.